Who Is Integrity Insurance?
Integrity Insurance is a regional property and casualty carrier headquartered in Appleton, Wisconsin, serving policyholders across the Midwest. With deep roots in the independent agency system, Integrity has built a strong reputation for personalized service, competitive auto and home rates, and a claims experience that reflects its name. The company focuses on the markets it knows best, delivering localized expertise that national carriers often cannot match.
Integrity works exclusively through independent agents like Better Choice Insurance Group, meaning you always have a local advocate who can shop your coverage across multiple carriers. Their product lineup includes auto, homeowners, renters, and umbrella coverage, all tailored to the needs of Midwestern families and property owners.
What They Are Known For
- Midwest expertise: Integrity focuses on states throughout the Midwest, giving them a deep understanding of regional risks like severe weather, hail, and winter driving conditions.
- Independent agency model: All Integrity policies are sold through independent agents, ensuring policyholders always have a local expert in their corner.
- Competitive auto and home rates: Integrity consistently delivers strong pricing on bundled auto and home policies, especially for Midwestern households.
- Mobile app access: The Integrity Insurance App gives policyholders on-the-go access to ID cards, policy details, and account management.
Quick Links — Integrity Insurance
Where We Write Integrity Insurance
Better Choice Insurance Group offers Integrity Insurance policies to homeowners and drivers across our service areas:
- Indiana: Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers
- Minnesota: Minneapolis, St. Paul, Bloomington