Trusted by thousands of policyholders

Insurance that works for you, not the other way around.

As an independent agency, we compare rates from 14+ top carriers to find you the best coverage at the lowest price. No bias. No hassle. Just better choices.

5.0 Google Rating
Licensed in multiple states
How It Works

Getting the right insurance shouldn't be complicated

Our simple 4-step process makes it easy to find the perfect coverage at the best price.

01

Tell Us What You Need

Share your coverage needs and we'll analyze your situation to identify the best options.

02

We Shop the Market

We compare rates from 14+ top-rated carriers to find the best coverage at the lowest price.

03

Review Your Options

We present you with side-by-side comparisons so you can make an informed decision.

04

Get Covered & Save

We handle all the paperwork and you start saving. It's that simple.

Our Partners

We partner with the nation's top carriers

Access to 14+ A-rated insurance carriers means more options, better coverage, and lower rates for you.

Travelers logoProgressive logoSafeco Insurance logoNationwide logoThe Hartford logoErie Insurance logoAuto-Owners Insurance logoKemper logoForemost Insurance logoWest Bend Mutual logoWestfield Insurance logoHanover Insurance logoBristol West logoMetLife logo
Why Better Choice

The advantage of independence

Unlike captive agents locked into a single carrier, we have the freedom to shop the entire market on your behalf. That means better options, better prices, and better service — every time.

Learn more about us

Independent & Unbiased

We work for you, not the insurance companies. Our independence means we always put your interests first.

Save Time & Money

We do the shopping for you, comparing rates from 14+ carriers to find the best deal — at no extra cost.

Expert Guidance

Our licensed agents have decades of combined experience navigating the insurance landscape.

Claims Advocacy

When you need to file a claim, we're in your corner — advocating for you every step of the way.

Personal Service

Talk to a real person who knows your name and your policy. No call centers, no runaround.

Annual Policy Reviews

We proactively review your coverage each year to ensure you always have the best rates and protection.

Testimonials

Don't just take our word for it

See why thousands of policyholders trust Better Choice Insurance Group.

Better Choice Insurance saved us over $1,200 a year on our auto and home bundle. The team was incredibly helpful and made the whole process painless.

Sarah M.
St. Charles, IL · Auto & Home Bundle

As a small business owner, I needed comprehensive coverage without breaking the bank. They found me the perfect policy and I couldn't be happier with the service.

Michael T.
Geneva, IL · Business Insurance

I was paying way too much for insurance. In just one call, they compared multiple carriers and cut my premium nearly in half. Highly recommend!

Jennifer L.
Batavia, IL · Auto Insurance

Start saving on your insurance today

Join thousands who have switched to Better Choice and saved an average of $600 per year. Get your free, no-obligation quote in minutes.